• @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    1624 days ago

    You could reduce meat intake and buy higher quality meat whenever financially feasible. Then you help fight the problem but can still look down on vegans

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      4324 days ago

      This is solid advice, but… you know… don’t look down on vegans maybe? They are trying to do the same thing (reduce animal suffering) but are able/willing to go above and beyond.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        1424 days ago

        Small incremental changes are easier to make than big ones. It is also better to have many people reducing meat than just a few full vegans.

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            724 days ago

            In my experience they often do go vegan overnight though. The key tends to be actually connecting the food on your plate with where it came from and accepting that animals are capable of suffering. Once that connection is made, animal products simply aren’t seen as food anymore and going vegan overnight is the only logical conclusion.

            Some people may be further along the spectrum towards being vegan when this connection is actually made but regardless of if you are vegetarian, “only eat free range meat”, or an unapologetic meat eater, once the connection is made they are vegan.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              English
              224 days ago

              “only eat free range meat”

              these people are by definiton not vegan. Trying to be more ethical by their choices, which is commendable - but not vegan.

              • @[email protected]
                link
                fedilink
                123 days ago

                Yes, that is my point. Whether someone is vegetarian, “trying to be more ethical” but still eating meat, or just a meat eater that has never even considered ethics, there is nothing that says you have to go through all of those steps to becoming vegan. In my experience, regardless of how far along you are in those “steps” once you make the connection between the food on your plate and the animals that it comes from and you realize that they are suffering for you, you go vegan. That could be meat eater to vegan, “ethical” meat eater to vegan, or vegetarian to vegan. My point is that in my experience that process does happen overnight.

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            English
            224 days ago

            I mean… reducing meat is how people would go vegan over longer period if time (as opposed to over night) though? Not sure where you were going with your original comment.

        • Doll_Tow_Jet-ski
          link
          fedilink
          624 days ago

          The word easier here is a choice. What is more comfortable is easier, but eating a plant based diet is very easy. It’s cheaper and widely available in most countries. What you mean by easier really refers to more comfortable, not really to there being less physical obstacles

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            1024 days ago

            not really to there being less physical obstacles

            Depends on availability. Plenty of eateries don’t have vegan options and this is especially true for locations accommodating larger groups. Furthermore, a lot of vegans need supplements (as I’ve been told), which is also subject to availability.

            Lastly, it’s easier to convince a thousand people to eat less meat – especially since they usually already have the ingredients required for vegetarian food at home – than to skip meat alltogether.

            Two thousand meals a week that turned vegetarian is a lot more impact than 70 meals turned vegan.

            • MrScottyTay
              link
              fedilink
              English
              724 days ago

              It’s not that a lot of vegans need supplements, they’re just more aware of what the body should get, when in fact almost everyone likely needs supplements. They just don’t know it.

            • Doll_Tow_Jet-ski
              link
              fedilink
              324 days ago

              Plenty of eateries don’t have vegan options

              Maybe you are thinking of processed vegan food, like a vegan nugget or hamburger. That is completely unnecessary. beans, lentils, chickpeas, seaweed, grains, rice, vegetables, nuts… those are widely available and enough for a healthy diet.

              For the rest I agree, it’s easier to convince an omnivore to go vegetarian than vegan. But that has to do with their will, not with actual physical limitations.

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            English
            124 days ago

            It is easy once you are in, know what are the good vegan meals and how to cook them etc. Most people will have animal product for each meal - they don’t know better. To them vegans just eat salads and nuts, which is obviously not enticing. If they don’t take the easy way, they will just continue the only way they know how and change nothing.

            • Doll_Tow_Jet-ski
              link
              fedilink
              123 days ago

              I agree with you. I guess the difference lies in that I would call that laziness. Not knowing how to eat balanced meals (or more precisely, not looking it up), it’s not a matter of it being hard or easy. It’s a matter of simply doing it. All the information is out there and at a level anyone who can read will understand

              • @[email protected]
                link
                fedilink
                English
                123 days ago

                I mean, you are not wrong. In a way easy way is always the lazy way - doesn’t mean it is wrong. It can be daunting. Some people will take the fast, but hard way. Some people will take the longer/ but easy. If you end up in same destination, it’s a win in the end.

                • Doll_Tow_Jet-ski
                  link
                  fedilink
                  120 days ago

                  Some people will take the fast, but hard way. Some people will take the longer/ but easy. If you end up in same destination, it’s a win in the end.

                  I guess you meant to say fast but easy, or longer but hard, right?

                  • @[email protected]
                    link
                    fedilink
                    English
                    120 days ago

                    I meant fast as in complete veganism overnight (hard) over slow, gradual change to eventually get to complete veganism (easier).

                    It’s not the usual way the phrase goes I guess, or I just worded it badly

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        924 days ago

        You will get more people to join your cause with a positive message: i.g. “Do these small steps to start” than a negative one, I.g. “If you don’t go fully vegan, you are still part of the problem.”

        “Perfect is the enemy of good.”

        So it is easier to convince people to reduce meat consumption, which than makes it more likely that people will go vegetarian or vegan later

        And i actually feel like vegans on the internet can be too aggressive, alienating people they could get on their side

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          724 days ago

          best is the enemy of better.

          why are you giving vegans advice on how to market veganism? if the facts won’t change your mind then it’s not the fault of the vegans.

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            324 days ago

            Because I want more people to become vegan and the way most people on the internet argue does not help this goal

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              324 days ago

              I also want more vegans. there is no right way to change someone’s mind. attack the problem from different angles is my view.

              All compassion is good compassion

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            324 days ago

            Of course facts can be aggressive

            Let’s assume you talk to someone from a first world country. It is aggressive to say your lifestyle is responsible for the death of children in the developmental world, you are indirectly a murderer

            It is more helpful to say: try fair-trade chlothes and check for companies that you buy from

            Dividing society does not help better it

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          324 days ago

          It’s kind of hard to approach this in a tactful way. I think a lot of why vegans don’t appreciate this approach is because it often doesn’t work in actual practice. I’ll give a personal example as an analogy - I used to be a smoker. I tried quitting at least 50 times over the time period I was addicted to nicotine. One of the tricks I would use was to reduce the amount I would smoke each day. It would help briefly, but what would always happen is that I would get to a point where it was too hard to reduce any further, and then after plateauing for a few days, I would rebound and smoke even more than I used to.

          Reduction still played a role in my effort to quit, but there were a lot of other tricks I had to employ to make it stick, and the overarching point is that reduction as a goal went nowhere, but reduction combined with the intent to stop all together did eventually work.

          And that’s what also happens with dietary changes. Reduction starts with halfway good intentions, but when it’s the goal it becomes a temporary self-soothe that simply ends up rebounding in the end. In fact the people who run wfpb health coaching clinics have stated in interviews that people are most successful when they go all in with the dietary changes - because it turns out that people often feel dramatic positive changes to their health within only days of going plant-based, and those positive changes reinforce their motivation to keep going.

          And as this article points out, reducitarianism can never achieve justice. It’s like when suits-wearers promise to reduce their carbon emissions by 10% by 2035 or something. It’s better than nothing, but will never solve the problems that need to be solved.

          https://www.surgeactivism.org/reducetarianism

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          123 days ago

          Your comment is about looking down on people… tongue in cheek or not, this is always the kind of stuff people post before complaining that the big mean vegans are alienating them… victim complex much?

      • MeanEYE
        link
        fedilink
        924 days ago

        Or vegans can just mind their own business and leave the rest alone. Claiming abuse and murder and yet still buy smartphones whose materials are sourced by abuse of the poor, drive around on liquefied animals and use plastics.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          1524 days ago

          Or animal abusers can just mind their own business and stop abusing and murdering innocent animals?

          • MeanEYE
            link
            fedilink
            424 days ago

            Stop using medicine and vaccines. K? Thank you. Those rely on horse shoe crabs donating blood and that’s animal abuse. Not to mention other medicine testing. Oh also, stop buying organic, since you know that’s exploitation of animals. Only veggies with good old artificial fertilizer are to be used. We don’t want you looking like a hypocrite while criticizing others.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              1124 days ago

              I’d rather be a hypocrite one out of ten days, than to systematically support animal abuse and murder to feed me - which can be done perfectly fine in harmless ways.

                  • MeanEYE
                    link
                    fedilink
                    224 days ago

                    Going vegan doesn’t mean you are saving animals. Without your demand for meat they would never get born in the first place. So not eating something that doesn’t get born doesn’t mean you saved them from being eaten. Just imagine how much potato milk I saved from being consumed, by not consuming potato milk.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              424 days ago

              Some vegans are against organic agriculture, and there currently is a huge problem where the various regenerative agricultural movements have been astroturfed by the animal ag industry with the whole free range thing.

              But it ignores that conventional industrial agriculture also appears to be sending almost the entire arthropod phylum into extinction, which is still worse than organic ag.

              There are a lot of reforms that need to be made to the agricultural sector, and veganic farming/gardening is one of those needed changes.

              • MeanEYE
                link
                fedilink
                224 days ago

                There are a lot of things that are not perfect in this world. But convenience trumps all, which is why diets reflect country’s policies and climate for the most part. USA shoves corn syrup into everything simply because of its abundance and everyone loves sweet stuff. But in the long run it’s creating a huge problem with obesity and diabetes. Meat is on the same level.

                For some climates meat comes off as a byproduct almost. Remaining plant matter from plants used for human consumption are normally used to feed cattle and other animals. Without animals all that would have been most likely burned. Even if there was a different way to repurpose that burning is the fastest and easiest thing and us humans love easy.

                Take for example countries in which sheep herding is a dominant form of farming because pastures can’t be used for anything else. You can’t expect those countries to ignore local food source which would be mutton and not use wool as byproduct, and rely solely on imported goods so they can go vegan. It’s impossible combined with stupidity. Look at Mongolia. Short grass as far as eye can see. Tell them not to rely on reindeer and meat.

                • @[email protected]
                  link
                  fedilink
                  424 days ago

                  I highly doubt this argument about the agricultural suitability of different lands holds up under scrutiny. I’ve seen someone grow a small food forest on top of a layer of manure that was spread on an abandoned parking lot, in midwest climate conditions. We don’t need the ‘viability’ of what can be grown where, being dictated by modern industrialized monoculture agribusinesses, since those practices are part of the problem.

                  And again it comes down to the possible and practical part of the vegan definition. I don’t live in Mongolia, so I’ll leave it to Mongolian vegans to determine what is and isn’t feasible.

                  This is just basic whataboutism.

        • MrScottyTay
          link
          fedilink
          English
          1324 days ago

          Vegans don’t see themselves as perfect. It’s all about doing the best you can, where you can

          • MeanEYE
            link
            fedilink
            324 days ago

            Which is fair enough and I can respect that. But I have no respect for assholes who think they are better than the rest and keep calling everyone murderer and animal abuser while they claim they can undo 100k+ years of evolution in a single life-time and hypocritically rely on modern medicine to keep them healthy.

            • MrScottyTay
              link
              fedilink
              English
              924 days ago

              Sorry to continue this on and be the kind of “but…” person.

              … But … A lot of vegans I know also try to reduce the amount of medicine they use cause sadly a lot of tablets have lactose in them. It’s genuinely one of the hardest things to deal with as a vegan, because it becomes the argument of do I better my life in spite of my ethics momentarily and it’s never an easy choice either way.

              • @[email protected]
                link
                fedilink
                624 days ago

                The way I see it is necessary suffering. There is no such thing as living without accidentally or implicitly causing suffering to someone, somewhere, so the logical response is harm reduction. Eating meat/cheese/eggs is not necessary. You won’t die or become ill if you stop. The calculation is not the same for medicine or food from agriculture generally.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              English
              324 days ago

              Just because some vegans are being assholes doesn’t mean you should be an asshole to everyone else and ignore the problem.

              • MeanEYE
                link
                fedilink
                123 days ago

                How am I being an asshole? My position from the start was that it’s your own thing to pick and choose what you eat. Am just saying preaching to others and acting smug about it is annoying.

                  • MeanEYE
                    link
                    fedilink
                    123 days ago

                    If their argument had any sense, yes. Something being popular doesn’t mean it’s right. Perhaps it’s time to give up od hypocrites and move on.

                • @[email protected]
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  123 days ago

                  Check the language you used for starters.

                  Vegans might be a bit preachy sometimes, because they want to change something that is a problem. It’s about raising awareness. Ultimately, it is up to you what you choose, no one can force you. Ultimately it is you ignoring a huge problem which is out there and choosing to do absolutely nothing about it.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          124 days ago

          Just because they do one good thing doesn’t mean they have to live the perfect life. It’s pretty hard to live in the modern world without a smartphone, while its realy not that hard to not eat animal products.

          • MeanEYE
            link
            fedilink
            123 days ago

            That’s all understandable and fine, but they don’t have the right to call others murderers and abuse condoners.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        524 days ago

        Put simply, promoting veganism won’t stop people from reducing, but promoting reducetarianism will stop people from going vegan

        This is either brain rot written by someone who doesn’t understand propaganda or a psy-op and I can’t tell which. So if it is a psy-op, congratulations on making an effective one.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          324 days ago

          Every doctor I’ve ever seen talk about diet, says that we should reduce our meat intake. They never suggest nor imply that people should go vegan as an alternative.

          At least, from my limited experience.

          I would argue that if someone has no intention of giving up meat, of which, there are plenty of people who are in that situation, then reduction can help improve the situation.

          If someone is considering, or at least would consider going vegan, then veganism is the right choice, reduction may make the transition more difficult in the long term.

          Thoughts? I’m happy to discuss. I just don’t have the time right this second to do a ton of reading/watching content about the other side of this discussion, so I’d like to know what you have to say.

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            English
            124 days ago

            reduction may make the transition more difficult in the long term.

            This is the only part that isn’t obviously true. Of course, this is a question of fact to be decided by evidence, but here’s my speculation:

            Given the size of the population, it’s clear that there will be some people who fall in either direction. Some people will find a gradual transition easier, some will be hindered by the possibility. I’m inclined to believe that it’d make things easier for more people than harder, but I have no basis of evidence to make that claim. It occurs to me that a general push to reduce meat consumption will also likely move the Overton window towards veganism, which would make large-scale vegan goals easier to achieve.

            Generally, when society at large is as far removed from a position as it is with veganism, advocating for a half-measure will tend to help the cause rather than hurt it. Veganism requires changing the minds of the entire world, and getting people acclimated to the idea that we eat too much meat will likely help with that.

            LMK if I wasn’t able to answer your question, or if you want to ask another one.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              English
              224 days ago

              I think you’re on the right track here, I would be hard pressed to disagree.

              The idea that reduction could hinder sometimes goals of becoming vegan is similar to any other habit or addiction. In some scenarios, reduction is the only option since cutting yourself off entirely can be fatal (methodone is one such example). In cases like smoking, going “cold turkey” can be significantly easier, since the idea is that you remove all of that item and all temptation to use it, from your life. Give yourself as few opportunities to fail as you can. You can’t pick up smoking again without going to get more cigarettes. That can be a fairly involved task to accomplish. If you have no cigarettes, you can’t not quit. In the same example context, reduction requires significant self control. Since you have the cigarettes, and nobody will stop you from having another. So it becomes entirely up to you to decide to reduce your intake. In that context, it’s easy to, instead of reducing your intake, you simply go back to your normal habits, causing your efforts to reduce/quit, to fail entirely.

              In the context of veganism, quitting by reduction still requires nontrivial willpower. It would be easy to grab a burger or pull out some other meat product to eat wherever you feel like it, and it can actively harm any efforts to be more vegan. Going the “cold turkey” route, you’ll have a few weeks of discomfort and cravings, but as long as you stick to it, within a month, you should not have those cravings (at least, not nearly as severe), anymore.

              It’s easy to mentally justify that it’s “just this once” or “I’ll do better tomorrow” when you’re deciding on a food option. However, if you go with an absolute disconnect of “if it has meat, say no” kind of thing, it would be harder to back slide into old habits.

              I dunno. I’m just saying words. Everyone is different. We should respect other people’s choices, whether that’s for veganism or not. It’s not like meat eaters are going around in their off time trapping chickens in closets for fun or anything. 90% either don’t know, don’t want to know, don’t care, or don’t feel like they can do anything about the factory farms. If they were informed, they would probably disagree with what’s happening, but ultimately not feel any personal responsibility to take further action. They’re not committing those kinds of atrocities, so it’s not them doing the bad thing.

              I know most vegans disagree with that mindset.

              I dunno.

              Anyone have some jerky?

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      224 days ago

      If your goal when choosing what to eat is “look down on vegans”, then you have a really shitty way of choosing what to eat.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        223 days ago

        Bruh,

        If getting made fun of helps reduce the amount of meat that gets eaten, this seems very much like a good deal to me